Me, Dior Me Not

The Verdict

Dior Me, Dior Me Not is one of those limited editions that inspires fierce loyalty in a small but dedicated group of fans. Released in 2004 as a playful riff on the childhood game "loves me, loves me not," it offered something unexpected from Dior: a youthful, lighthearted floral that felt more like a breath of fresh air than a statement of luxury. Its discontinuation sparked genuine mourning among its admirers, many of whom continue to hope for a relaunch.

The community's assessment is characteristically split. Some consider it one of the finest fragrances they have ever owned, praising its ability to make them feel fresh, happy, and gorgeous simultaneously. Others find it too simple, too sweet, and too girly for a house with Dior's stature. The truth, as usual, lies somewhere between these poles.

What It Smells Like

The opening presents sweet pea alongside water notes that create a dewy, green freshness. There is an immediate impression of something light and translucent, like morning dew on flower petals. Some reviewers detect a strangeness in the sweet pea note that reads as slightly synthetic, though others find it charming and natural.

The heart blooms into peony, freesia, and violet, a classic spring garden trio that provides gentle sweetness without becoming cloying. The peony is the most prominent note here, giving the composition a soft, romantic character. The base settles into crystal musk with a hint of cherry, creating a clean, youthful foundation that keeps the fragrance feeling modern rather than old-fashioned.

When to Wear It

Dior Me, Dior Me Not was created for warm-weather enjoyment. Its light, aquatic-floral character suits spring and summer days perfectly, whether for casual outings, garden parties, or light office wear. It is the kind of fragrance that can be worn "anytime and anywhere" according to its admirers, though its youthful character makes it most natural in relaxed, daytime settings.

Longevity & Projection

Longevity is one of the more commonly cited drawbacks. As an Eau de Toilette, it was never designed for all-day staying power, and reviewers report moderate longevity that falls short of what many expect from the Dior name. The crystal musk base provides a soft, skin-scent persistence after the florals fade, but the vibrant top and heart notes are relatively short-lived. Projection is gentle and appropriate for its character, creating a soft cloud of floral freshness without overwhelming.

The Community Says

Fragrantica reviewers offer the widest range of opinions. One calls it "one of the most precious Dior perfumes," describing how the "aquatic notes are so mild and refreshing." Another flatly declares it "a Dior me not for me," finding the sweet pea "very strange and unpleasant." The Osmoz review positions it as a fragrance created for "the young woman who searches for refreshment and sensual notes." Basenotes catalogers note its limited edition status and floral woody musk classification. Several reviewers across platforms express displeasure at its discontinuation, with some noting they have received many compliments while wearing it.

Who Should Buy This

Dior Me, Dior Me Not appeals most to those who appreciate light, youthful florals and who value charm over complexity. It makes an excellent introduction to the world of designer fragrance for younger wearers, and Dior collectors will find it a worthwhile addition. However, those seeking the weight, depth, and longevity associated with the Dior name will likely find it too insubstantial.

The Bottom Line

Dior Me, Dior Me Not is a charming, lighthearted floral that captured something genuinely appealing in its brief production run. Its sweet pea-peony heart and dewy freshness create a feel-good wearing experience that its fans remember fondly. Whether that charm justifies the collector prices now attached to remaining bottles is a personal calculation, but there is no denying that this little limited edition left an outsized impression on those who discovered it.